• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Jazzbo

Member
  • Posts

    22
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Jazzbo

  1. I am attempting to acquire a nice set of San Francisco Morgans and a coupe of months ago I sent NGC 15 different San Francisco Morgans for grading, not the early year commons. I spent the past 18 months acquiring them raw from various sales, coin shows, etc and felt all were uncirculated MS 60 or better with the exception of one or two that would be in high AU 50's. Because I thought they would all do well and they were for my personal collection I requested each coin have the NGC conservation. What a disappointment when I received them back, here's what NGC said.

    1883 S $1 AU Details, Cleaned
    1885 S $1 MS 62
    1886 S $1 MS 61
    1887 S $1 MS 61
    1888 S $1 MS 60
    1889 S $1 UNC Details, Cleaned
    1890 S $1 AU 58
    1891 S $1 MS 60
    1894 S $1 UNC, Details, Cleaned
    1897 S $1 MS 62
    1898 S $1 AU 55
    1899 S $1 MS 61
    1900 S $1 MS 62
    1901 S $1 AU 55
    1902 S $1 AU, Details, Rev Damage

    I'm not a novice, help enlighten me with questions I have. First question, does anyone see a pattern on the grading and value of the coin? How about that they did conservation on each coin, charged me for it and still labeled it cleaned? I know there can be old tell tale signs but it still I saw nothing whatsoever...... How about the 1902 with reverse damage that clearly looks like bag mark scratches from other coins rubbing on it?

  2. Hello, I took the following screen shot from the Collection Manager this afternoon. I have several 2016-W NGC MS70 Proofs that had NGC values automatically populated a couple of months ago

    but don't now. I also manually entered the NGC certification number of some of the coins and no value appears. Is something broken or are you not providing values for these coins any longer?

    Thank you.

    image.thumb.png.e2bc4cfd74e3b7bc852ee414df6dc84a.png

     

  3. Over the weekend I received back from NGC 15 San Francisco Mogan dollars I submitted for grading. On my submission form I stated I did not want any coin NGC would deem as cleaned or would give a details grade to. I obtained information about this request which could be made on this NGC forum that it could be requested. I understand I would have to still pay for the grading but didn't want any coin they thought had been cleaned or details slabbed. Guess what? Slabbed, I received 3 back with details cleaned and 1 details damage. Why wasn't my request honored?