CHARLES MOORE

I  would also like to know the Status of PCGS coins for  the Registry, I sent in four PCGS coins  for a crossover to  the NGC label. I didn't ask for an upgrade. Just wanted the four PCGS coins (Morgan Dollars)  to crossover to NGC with the same grade, All four PCGS coins were rejected. What are the odds of 100% rejections of four PCGS  Morgan dollars of different dates?

This request has happened to me several times. When a person requests a transfer and the coin is in your possession and you reject it and then hear nothing further then it should be obviuos to NGC that the request was invalid.I would like to know  what sort of Penalty NGC assigns to the person requesting the transfer when they have to know that the coin is not in their possession? There should be a suspension etc, for it. The other poster is correct in that they might be on vacation and not be aware of the request and in three days their coin is transferred from them.

There are some instances where price is not available when  the label  is not the usual label especially when the label has a certain official signature such as the Treasurer of the United States etc. I don't think that a label  with such a signature would decrease the value and maybe it would or wouldn't increase the value, It would seem to me that NGC could assign the value for the   the coin in that grade regardless of the label. So if you had an MS70 coin for a Coin  that it would be assigned the value for that coin   in that grade regardless of the label.

On 4/13/2017 at 1:06 AM, KDG710 said:

This is a big mistake!  Are we collecting coins or holders?  Now we have the label scam, it's no longer the coin but the SPECIAL labels and the holder that control the price. (Soon Mickey Mouse will be signing labels) To make things worse we pay top dollar for these special labels and they aren't even reflected in the collection manager, I have many John Mercanti signed labels but when entering the cert# they come up as any other coin and the price of the standard brown labels. ie 1994 P PF70 UC Mercanti signed label with a price guide of $1500!  2016 W PF 70UC Mercanti FDOI enter cert# comes up as 2016 W PF70UCFDOI with a price of $95! I couldn't buy these coins for that price anywhere Pre-sales were $129, now you can't find one to buy under $189 if at all

This makes it very hard to justify why I'm buying these SPECIAL holders when it always shows me I'm losing money, buy a coin for $895 only to have NGC tell me it's only worth $375.  You sell the labels and grade the coins PLEASE update your database to reflect the proper labeling and pricing.

Thanks

I recently sent in 4 PCGS Coins in their holders  for a cross over to  the NGC label of the same  grade. All four were Morgan Dollars. I paid $198 for the four coins and the Standard I spent $46 for the postage and insurance for a total of $244. This is $61.00 for each coin whether the coin is re-holdered or not.I posted on another area where several months ago somebody tried to transfer a coin in my possession to their Registry and NGC made me submit my coin for evaluation and even cancelled the certification number so I couldn't keep it in my Registry and had to send it in to NGC and it took them several weeks to grade my coin and return it even though it had always been in my possession.I kept asking whether  the person requesting the transfer of  the coin in my possession was asked to do the same with no answer from NGC., My coin was an NGC graded coin and was eventually returned to me in the same grade and a new certification number,  I have to ask what would have happened if this coin had been in a PCGS holder and could have been  graded below  it grade even though I was subjected to having to prove that a coin that had been in my possesssion for some time just because somebody else that obviously did not have the coin requested it. Rejecting all four PCGS coins is a 100% rejection. Who is going to pay $61 a coin for 100% rejection?Not me.

NGC had a slot for the 2022  S ASE and many people inckuding myself bought it for that reason . Recently NGC removed this coin from all parties in the Registry.  and kept the 2022 W ASE Chicago ANA. This caused the people who purchased it to lose 575 points while people that did not purchase it lost nothing. Is it possible that some moderator  confused the 2022 S  ASE Chicago ANA with the 2022 W  ASE Chicago ANA and deleted it thinking it was duplicated,. The 2022 S ASE Chicago ANA is different from the 2022  W  ASE Chicagp/

I recently purchased an NGC slabbed   2019  1oz     Canada  Peace and Liberty  Official Mint   Medal and can't find a Registry for it. It would seem that the most  Logical one would  be Tokens and Medals ,however, this is not the case. Does anybody know the name of the Registry for it?