Newest addition to my collection of Morgan dollars

So I recently have been searching for the perfect 1888-P Morgan dollar for my set. My goal was to find one with good strike and attractive to the eye in MS65.

I have had a hard time finding one with both qualities at a good price.

here's my situation.....

I finally found one that looks awesome! All the qualities I was looking for. Great detail on the key points of the surface and great luster! I truly have not seen a 65 that has looked this good yet! Now, I can get it for $240 which I think is fair when I look at all the others I have seen in the $225 price range.

But, I also found a semi-nice 65 with the star designation for $260. Its an extra 150 points in the registry for $20 more. But it doesn't have nearly the strike quality the cheaper one has.

I bought the cheaper one without the star because of how awesome the detail is compared to the last, probably, 200 1888 ms65 Morgans I have seen.

Any thoughts? Should I have gone for the more points and star with weaker strike?

Anyone have any experience in these situations. I truly wanted the better coin, in my eyes.

P.S. I will have detailed pics when it comes In if anyone is interested in seeing it.

Thanks for stopping by

nick