You make the call

I have posted a photo of a 2010 American Silver Eagle coin. I sold this coin to a good customer of mine and then customer brought the coin back to me because the L in liberty was nicked. His statement was, it was not a prefect coin and should not have been graded as a MS70 by NGC. Well I looked at the 2011 ASE and the coin had an imperfection on the L in Liberty. I ponied up the cash and sent the coin in question to NGC for an Appearance Review. I received the coin back today and a nice letter which states "This silver eagle meets the requirements for MS70 by NGC standards. Take a look at the coin and you tell me is this a MS70 coin in your book?

To see old comments for this Journal entry, click here. New comments can be added below.