Part 2

hi coinman....

to address your point, but for the sake of brevity, 'I put the coins in my pocket'...should have included every thing you mentioned....I wasn't brutal but the coins saw a lot of attention...

I was not trying to lower coins incrementally, I started with coins that graded the 64 - 66 spread most fell in....and as JTO stated....the 58 has the appearance of a higher grade with high point wear or 'breaking the luster'....every coin I submitted had high point luster 'broken'....that was my criteria for wear....even as slight as it was...

NGC thought differently and gave me the grades I posted....thanks for your input everyone...

To see old comments for this Journal entry, click here. New comments can be added below.