Crack in case for a PCGS Morgan Cc 1 1

[Mr.Bill347]

Is this a concern ? Number verified as indicated. Price is pretty good.

What do you guys think about it?

[Mr.Bill347]

How about this one ungraded. Is it real?

 

[bsshog40]

Small crack in slab wouldn't bother me. 2nd coin looks like it's been cleaned to me. 

[James Zyskowski]

Agree. Small crack is personal. For me I would pass unless a bargain.  
Now the second coin is showing signs of cleaning and not gentle. CC ‘s are tough because I don’t have one (except the 2021🤨) and keep finding stuff like you are. This or that, almost but not really. If I am going to buy one I’m going to wait a couple years. The prices are crazy or there’s a problem. Not to say that if the slabbed CC is priced right I’d jump, but carefully 😉

[Coinbuf]

The raw coin is a cleaned AU, very hard pass.   The one in the PCGS holder looks off, there is the crack which is more of a personal thing than a concern by itself.    However the label looks wrong as it should be a lite blue and in your photos it looks white, additionally there appears to be some gunk (for lack of a better word) around the edge of the holder and I'm concerned that this coin has not been properly stored and subjected to humidity, heat, water, or some combination of those.    I also am not a fan of the black spots around the rim, those lower the eye appeal to most collectors.

These are very common and easily found nice, I would run away from both of these, there is a reason why the slabbed one is a "bargain".   Good coins are seldom cheap and cheap coins are seldom good, the old saying that you get what you pay for seems to apply to these coins.

[RWB]

The second coin appears to be real -- but also a "real dog."  Cleaned, scrubbed and not really worth buying even at a big discount - it will be tough to resell later.

[MN1]

If it's that spot near the 4:00 position I could live with it...if it was a coin I wanted bad enough and difficult to get.  However the 1882-CC, 1883-CC, and 1884-CC Morgans are the most common.  I picked a 1882-CC up in the GSA holder with the box and COA for what I considered cheap.  I'd keep looking.  There are more out there.  I see them at Flea Markets in the GSA holder.  

[Mr.Bill347]

Thanks guys, I’ll pass on it this time!