* Grade Revealed* 1876-CC SLQ

[FishyOne]

 

 

I may have over-paid a bit, but I liked the looks of this SLQ. What do you think? She's in a problem-free holder.

 

[James_OldeTowne]

VF-25.

[coinman_23885]

I may have over-paid a bit, but I liked the looks of this SLQ. What do you think? She's in a problem-free holder.

 

My experience with Carson City Seated Liberty Dimes and Quarters is that they (or at least the uncirculated versions) sell for a bit more than both the NGC and PCGS Price Guides. I recall losing a couple by a sizable difference when my bid was the price guide value.

[L1ncolnF4n]

VF

 

I like it over 20 but don't know if I like 25.

[Coincrazed74]

I like it Fishy! Looks VF.

[johnny9434]

ill go vf as well.

[michael]

i love the coin

 

perfect grey original surfaces

 

no serious nicks, cuts, marks, edge bangs, uneven toning and with above average eye appeal

 

basically a gem circulated coin

 

"GEM CIRC."

 

yea i agree i would call it vf-25

 

and all there vf-25+ no more no less

 

and sexy extremely SEXY with the 76 date and cc mintmark

 

if if only had this coin in your collection it would be good as

it is a stand alone coin

[relicsncoins]

Nice coin.....put me down for VF25.

[Chris1976]

I feel its VF25 as well. I've seen worse as a 30 locally (dealer agree's that his is overgraded)

[coinman_23885]

I agree with the other posters; solid VF 25.

[FishyOne]

Grade in first post. She's a VF25.

 

I picked this one up on Heritage Tuesday night. Had to go to $125 though. A little high but the originality and honest wear won me over. The price guides are all over the place on this date in VF20. PCGS is $145 and NGC is $81!

 

Needless to say, these don't often go for $80 when problem-free.

 

Thanks for all the comments!

[Coincrazed74]

Congrats on a nice coin Fishy! Even though you it's high, you like it and that is what matters!

[coinman_23885]

Grade in first post. She's a VF25.

 

I picked this one up on Heritage Tuesday night. Had to go to $125 though. A little high but the originality and honest wear won me over. The price guides are all over the place on this date in VF20. PCGS is $145 and NGC is $81!

 

Needless to say, these don't often go for $80 when problem-free.

 

Thanks for all the comments!

 

I think the NGC Guide is low based on what I have seen, and the PCGS Guide (at least the example that you cite) seems fair. As I indicated previously, I have seen several CC seated liberty coins sell for above guide for average grade coins (i.e. solid grade, not PQ per se, etc.). I like your coin.

[James_OldeTowne]

Grade in first post. She's a VF25.

Needless to say, that's the correct grade and I completely agree with it !