If at first you don’t succeed you can always resubmit.

[currentcoin]

I had to resubmit a few dime I knew were not graded right.

 

Here are the before (top) and after (bottom) of the same coins.

 

 

I guess graders are infallible.

 

Glen

[currentcoin]

See I screwed up the pictures

 

No one is infallible

 

Glen

[Leothelion]

I had to resubmit a few dime I knew were not graded right.

 

Here are the before (top) and after (bottom) of the same coins.

 

 

I guess graders are infallible.

 

Glen

 

Send them in a third time and you'll end up with some new lottery numbers!

 

Leo

 

3 for 3 pcgs graded screw-ups! This really goes to show how credible all those pcgs registry sets are!

[gmarguli]

Clearly this is a hoax. PCGS could not screw up like this. They are gods. You are BANNED!!!

[braddick]

Unbelievable!

[Hoot]

WOW! Great stuff. I've had a few resubmissions change one point AND get the correct designation, but never two points! Well, I have had a couple BB'd coins get correctly graded a second time around!

 

Hoot

[Elcontador]

This is precisely why I don't submit many coins. I can see a change in designation, say, re a liner FH or no FH on an SLQ, though I wouldn't buy such a coin in the first place. I could also see a one point grading difference. This happened to me once when I submitted a Walker, came back MS 65. I thought it was nicer than that, sent it in for in-holder regrading & it came back MS 66.

 

Unless you're dealing with a really tough series to grade, like Capped Bust Halves, I think a 2 point difference between submissions of the same coin is not acceptable. I don't know many coins where someone who knows how to grade them can't tell the difference between a MS 64& a MS 66. That being said, I do not collect moderns.

[shirohniichan]

I don't know many coins where someone who knows how to grade them can't tell the difference between a MS 64& a MS 66. That being said, I do not collect moderns.

 

Modern slab basher! BURN HIM!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

 

[James_OldeTowne]

As someone not familiar with buying/selling coins like these, is there really much difference in value for the given grades?

 

James

[currentcoin]

James

The difference moneywise is about 500 times, Non FB vs FB

 

Glen