What do you think?........Did it get the "Star"

[Schatzy]

Link to the Coin!!

 

 

Well I sent the coin into NGC for the designation review to see if I could get the Star!!

 

I think the coin looks better in hand!!

 

 

The coin just hit quality control today so well see soon!!

 

[MunkyMan95]

No star.

[chinook]

I've seen stars on much less attractive coins. And more attractive coins that didnt receive stars. So I guess you just flip a coin on this.

[BECOKA]

It may be better in hand but by the photo I'd say no star.

[James_OldeTowne]

No star.

 

My rationale is that the coin is already CAM, and I actually can't remember offhand a CAM that was additionally blessed with a "star".

 

By the way, the coin IS a "star" in my eyes!

[RareSov]

I voted yes, good luck

[Schatzy]

By the way, the coin IS a "star" in my eyes!

 

She is also a star in my eyes and even if NGC doesn't give me the star, I am still going to keep the coin.

I never done the designation review so I just wanted to give it a try!!

[bsshog40]

I didn't vote because I don't really know what methods they use to determine a Star designation but I think it looks worthy of one in my personal opinion.

[123cents]

To get the star I think it would have to have exceptional eye appeal. I think it might have a good chance if it does look better in hand.

[realone]

pretty darn nice, i would think it is deserving of one whether they gave it or not.

[kryptonitecomics]

I don't see anyway it gets a star but....

 

I have sent in plenty deserving of stars that didn't get the designation and I have even sent in a few I was surprised got the star.....so anything is possible

 

 

[gpnyc]

That's the type of coin the Star designation was created for. I will go out on a limb and say its a sure thing.

[Dwaine]

I say no star

[rrantique]

I say no star

 

But there is always hope.

[Schatzy]

Well guys I thought for sure that it would move out of quality control today but I guess we will have to want till Monday!!

[Glossy]

No star.

 

My rationale is that the coin is already CAM, and I actually can't remember offhand a CAM that was additionally blessed with a "star".

 

By the way, the coin IS a "star" in my eyes!

 

Cam and Ultra Cam stars do exist. I own a 1952 PF 68* Cam Roosie, NGC has graded only 3 in that grade. The other two exhibit nice toning like Jaime's coin. Good luck with your submission, I hope you get it!! (thumbs u

[PCcoins]

As Shane said, anything is possible. But IMO I say NO

[coinman1794]

No star.

 

My rationale is that the coin is already CAM, and I actually can't remember offhand a CAM that was additionally blessed with a "star".

 

By the way, the coin IS a "star" in my eyes!

 

Cam and Ultra Cam stars do exist. I own a 1952 PF 68* Cam Roosie, NGC has graded only 3 in that grade. The other two exhibit nice toning like Jaime's coin. Good luck with your submission, I hope you get it!! (thumbs u

 

They do exist, and usually a " STAR CAM" coin has an ULTRA obverse paired with a CAM reverse. A " STAR ULTRA " will have an obverse well beyond ULTRA contrast.

 

However, it's important to remember there are two ways of getting the STAR. Exceptional obverse contrast, and exceptional eye appeal. The dime in question is eligable for the STAR because of its exceptional eye appeal, not an ULTRA CAM obverse. Thus, the contrast won't necessarily factor into their decision on this piece.